M, b. circa 1836, d. before 1920
| Birth2 | Aug 1834 | Conflicting evidence states that John was born at VA in Aug 1834.1 |
| Birth* | c 1836 | John was born at Fayette Co, VA, c 1836. |
| | He was the son of James Settle and Rachel Johnson. |
| (Witness) Census | 26 Aug 1850 | John W. Settle appeared on the census of 26 Aug 1850 in the household of Enoch Light and Rachel Johnson at District 14, Fayette Co, VA.2 |
| Marriage* | | John W. Settle married Amy Johnson, daughter of James Johnson and Mary Elizabeth "Betsy" Murphy.2 |
| Employment* | Jun 1860 | Occupation: farmer in Jun 1860 at Fayette Co, WV.2 |
| Census* | 27 Jun 1860 | A census listed John as head of household at District 2, Fayette Co, VA, on 27 Jun 1860.2 |
| Employment | Aug 1870 | Occupation: farmer in Aug 1870 at Fayetteville Twp, Fayette Co, WV.2 |
| Census | 29 Aug 1870 | A census listed John as head of household at Fayetteville Twp, Fayette Co, WV, on 29 Aug 1870.2 |
| (informant) Death | Mar 1878 | John was informant for the death of Amy Johnson at Fayette Co, WV, in Mar 1878.3 |
| Marriage* | 16 Feb 1879 | He married Mary Isabella Bragg at Fayette Co, WV, on 16 Feb 1879. John W. Suttle, age 40, widowed, b. Fayette Co, WV, par. Jas & R; Mary I. Bragg, age 21, single, b. Fayette Co, WV, par. H. & R.4 |
| Employment | Jun 1880 | Occupation: farmer in Jun 1880 at Fayetteville Dist, Fayette Co, WV.2 |
| Census* | 5 Jun 1880 | A census listed John as head of household at Fayetteville Dist, Fayette Co, WV, on 5 Jun 1880.2 |
| Employment | Jun 1900 | Occupation: farmer in Jun 1900 at Fayetteville Dist, Fayette Co, WV.2 |
| Census | 22 Jun 1900 | A census listed John as head of household at Fayetteville Dist, Fayette Co, WV, on 22 Jun 1900.2 |
| Employment | May 1910 | Occupation: farmer in May 1910 at Dempsey Precinct, Fayette Co, WV.2 |
| Census | 25 May 1910 | A census listed John as head of household at Dempsey Precinct, Fayette Co, WV, on 25 May 1910.2 |
| Death* | b 1920 | He died b 1920..2 |